Ever since the woman he once adored told Jay he was a chivalrous hero, he tries to live up to the praise. But dating other girls proves to be a chore, until he meets fellow Harvard student Sarah. He discovers they have much in common, but also that getting to know the shy pianist is painful. The last thing Jay expects from his friendly advances is to be assaulted by a brawny stranger. It is clear someone wants him to stay away from Sarah. If only he could.