Klik på en miniature for at gå til Google Books
Indlæser... Memoirs of a Superfluous Man (1943)af Albert Jay Nock
Ingen Indlæser...
Bliv medlem af LibraryThing for at finde ud af, om du vil kunne lide denne bog. Der er ingen diskussionstråde på Snak om denne bog. This book puts Nock squarely in the doom and gloom libertarian camp — predicting that the world is going to pot and wishing for the "good old days". Thankfully for us, the world has remained in one piece, and as a sometimes member of that camp, I found that comforting. However, his prophecies are based on something unusual — the shortcomings of ordinary people. Many libertarians place the blame elsewhere and believe that people are freedom loving at heart, but Nock see it differently, and this view was though provoking but also somewhat disconcerting. I think that he gets many things wrong, but the ideas were worth some mulling over. Also, I found many of the stories interesting because of their mix of observation and insight. He wrote in something of a high falutin style, but I could deal with that. Still, some parts of the book reminded me of Twain's Roughing It. I liked it a lot — 5 stars. ingen anmeldelser | tilføj en anmeldelse
Albert Jay Nock, perhaps the most brilliant American essayist of the 20th century, and certainly among its most important libertarian thinkers, set out to write his autobiography but he ended up doing much more. He presents here a full theory of society, state, economy, and culture, and does so almost inadvertently. His stories, lessons, observations, and conclusions pack a very powerful punch, so much so that anyone who takes time to read carefully cannot but end up changed in intellectual outlook. One feels that one has been let in a private club of people who see more deeply than others. This is truly an American classic. If a regime of complete economic freedom can be established, social and political freedom will follow automatically; and until it is established neither social nor political freedom can exist. Here one comes in sight of the reason why the State will never tolerate the establishment of economic freedom. In a spirit of sheer conscious fraud, the State will at any time offer its people "four freedoms," or six, or any number; but it will never let them have economic freedom. If it did, it would be signing its own death-warrant, for as Lenin pointed out, "It is nonsense to make any pretense of reconciling the State and liberty." Our economic system being what it is, and the State being what it is, all the mass verbiage about "the free peoples" and "the free democracies" is merely so much obscene buffoonery. -Albert Jay Nock No library descriptions found. |
Current DiscussionsIngenPopulære omslag
Google Books — Indlæser... GenrerMelvil Decimal System (DDC)814.52Literature English (North America) American essays 20th Century 1901-1945LC-klassificeringVurderingGennemsnit:
Er det dig?Bliv LibraryThing-forfatter. |
Regarding the popular classical works (Caesar, Homer, Virgil, Cicero), Nock felt this was the "dullest, dreariest, most unrewarding task I ever set my hand to." Instead the "scraps" used in his learning Greek and Latin taught him affairs of ordinary life and experience which made him see "men and women of antiquity ... not as heroes, but as people exaclty like us, each with twenty-four hours a day to get through somehow or other and for the most part getting throguh them quite as we do," while the "great orator was a good deal of a stuffed shirt."
"Nine-tenths of the value of classical studies lies in their power to establish a clear common-sense, matter-of-fact view of human nature and its activities over a continuous stretch of some twenty centuries." "Too often a routing of elementary Greek and Latin was forced upon ineducable children." "I have seen many a graduate student who had gone to Germany to study under some great classicist, like a colour-blind botanist going to a flower-show with a bad cold in his head; he came back a a doctor of philosophy, knowing a great deal about his subject, I dare say, but not knowing how to appreciate or enjoy it."
In discussing the industrial revolution and ensuing prosperity, he brings out the this-cannot-last fears that seemed to underly the thoughts of many. Economism was the only philosophy; the "whole of human life in terms of the production, acquisition and distribution of wealth." "I sometimes thought of the rich lumbermen whom I had known so well, and on the whole had rather liked. Now I ws looking at the great avatars of their practical philosophy, the Carnegies, Rockefellers, Fricks, Hills, Huntingtons, of the period. I asked myself whether any amount of wealth would be worth having if - as one most efficiently must - if one had to become just like these men in order to get it. To me, at least, it would not; I should be a superfluous man in the scuffle for riches."
Nock continues onward with constantly interesting insight, including 3 simple laws that explain so many human trends. They're beautiful. Want to know? Read the book. ( )