Recommended: yes
For an introduction to a promising new fantasy series, for political scheming and world-threatening dangers to your heart’s content, for elaborate growth of the main character built steadily throughout

Thoughts:
Points for unexpected plot twists, that felt believable and acceptable. None of this plot twist where it’s too outrageous or feels like an excuse (“It was all a dream!”). I’m a little bloodthirsty so maybe I wanted something different in some cases, but I still enjoyed it. All the elements I had hoped for re: the world of darkness were satisfied and more is promised. Now the challenge is waiting for the next book to release next year.

This is a fairly hefty book, in length and content. It has a pretty slow start, with a lot of setup for the kingdoms in the world, the cultures and clashes between them, and a whole lot of political negotiation complicated by mysterious deadly artifacts. Most of the action happens in the latter half of the book. Don’t expect to rush through this; it’s best to sit down ready to learn about the world.

She just knows that sometimes you have to destroy in order to protect.

Since this is also the first book in a series, a lot of the exposition is out of the way here. I expect to walk into book two with a solid understanding of the world, characters, motivation, and very dramatic problems they’re all trying to resolve. I do hope for more of a balance in the next book between active adventure and conflict, and the scheming cultural politics.

The beginning is filled with characters I (rightfully) loathed. They seem to have no redeeming characteristics and exist more as a foil to Ryx and to see what she’s had to deal with all these years. They largely felt like black-and-white personalities with no shades of gray. This is the mean aunt, this is the brash cousin, and so on. The core group that you see more of in the latter half are more developed and far more likable and interesting. I want to get to know them more!

And, of course, the magic. I love the different ways the kingdoms handle magic. In Vaskandar, mage bloodlines control states and help their cities with their magic (ex. helping with a harvest, creating chimeras for battle, etc). But the Serene Empire seeks balance in status, so mages are cuffed and their ability to use magic tied to a non-magical person. The kinds of magic, the realms of thought around it, and the debates about equality, freedom, and security resound back into current societal issues.

Also FYI for representation: this is a great example of how characters can have traits that are part of them but aren’t the only thing that defines them. Bisexual, asexual, non-binary: someone can feel any of these things and still have exciting adventures and other character traits!!! Books that investigate the experience are important as well, but I do so love when an adventure story just includes elements like this without characters batting an eye. Total acceptance to the point of it registering as a fact like “their eyes are brown.” ♥

Thanks to Orbit and NetGalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review! ( )

I enjoyed Ms Caruso's first series "Swords and Fire" a lot. It was very much my type of fantasy. So I had bought the first of this new series but waited to start it until it was all published. I enjoyed this beginning too, although the main character Ryx's voice did very much remind me of the voice of the main character in the first trilogy. But it was easy to read and I was never bored. ( )

DNF - very boring, far too much information thrown at me at the beginning made it hard to follow (I felt like I was dropped into the book a few chapters in when I should already know the characters and setting), just couldn't get into it. ( )

Ehhhh, too YA-ey. I was hopeful in the first chapter or two for cool diplomacy stuff, but I stopped in the middle of "omg I finally get to go to the ball!" which is extremely not my jam.

More fast, furious fun in Eruvia as a new generation faces new threats to the fragile balance of power.

Those seeking more of the same will be delighted by the Vaskandran perspective and magically-challenged heroine; those looking for something new may find this a little too similar to Swords and Fire (magic aside, there’s little to separate Ryx and Amalia; and villains are as ludicrously over the top as heroes are good-hearted and loyal). I enjoyed it as a rousing adventure in a familiar context that sets up what promises to be a diverting new trilogy - and I adore the Rookery.

Full review ( )