HjemGrupperSnakMereZeitgeist
Søg På Websted
På dette site bruger vi cookies til at levere vores ydelser, forbedre performance, til analyseformål, og (hvis brugeren ikke er logget ind) til reklamer. Ved at bruge LibraryThing anerkender du at have læst og forstået vores vilkår og betingelser inklusive vores politik for håndtering af brugeroplysninger. Din brug af dette site og dets ydelser er underlagt disse vilkår og betingelser.

Resultater fra Google Bøger

Klik på en miniature for at gå til Google Books

Indlæser...

The Anarchist in the Library: How the Clash Between Freedom and Control Is Hacking the Real World and Crashing the System (2004)

af Siva Vaidhyanathan

MedlemmerAnmeldelserPopularitetGennemsnitlig vurderingOmtaler
421859,104 (3.4)3
"The recording industry has sued the music downloaders into submission, but as a model of communication, their effects still echo around the world. The proliferation of such peer-to-peer networks may appear to threaten many established institutions, and the backlash against them could be even worse than the problems they create. Their effects - good and bad - resonate far beyond markets for music. They are altering our sense of the possible, extending our cultural and political imaginations." "Unregulated networks of communication have existed as long as gossip has. But with the rise of electronic communication, they are exponentially more important. And they are drawing the contours of a struggle over information that will determine much of the culture and politics of our century, from unauthorized fan edits of Star Wars to terrorist organizations' reliance on "leaderless resistance." The Anarchist in the Library is the first guide to one of the most important cultural and economic developments of our time."--Jacket.… (mere)
Ingen
Indlæser...

Bliv medlem af LibraryThing for at finde ud af, om du vil kunne lide denne bog.

Der er ingen diskussionstråde på Snak om denne bog.

» Se også 3 omtaler

Viser 1-5 af 8 (næste | vis alle)
Four stars not because the writing is especially good, but because I think the content is pretty important. Not just for librarians, but for anyone who uses the internet, really. The Goodreads synopsis describes it as a "guide to one of the most important cultural and economic battlegrounds" — the battleground in question being the internet. I can't say I agree with everything he says, but it did get me to think about the nature of the Internet and creativity and control in different ways. The stuff on Napster seems dated now, so I skipped over those parts, but yeah, totally recommend reading it. ( )
  hms_ | Nov 22, 2022 |
The Anarchist in the Library is Vaidhyanathan’s second book on copyright and intellectual property (IP) after his 2003 Copyrights and Copywrongs. Where the earlier book was a straightforward and lively history of this area of law and culture, in The Anarchist in the Library Vaidhyanathan tries to put a socio-philosophical spin on the same material to achieve an apocalyptic excitement. For a number of reasons, it doesn’t work.

Vaidhyanathan tries to cram all the complex issues surrounding copyright and IP, which include those of music downloading and sampling, software and media “piracy,” print publishing, control of libraries (as in the Patriot Act), control of computer networks as well as the little publicized area of IP in science (genomics, pharmaceuticals, and so on), inside two buckets: the totalitarian “controllers” and the free-for-all “anarchists.” The alleged “clash” between the two buckets, Vaidhyanathan claims, is “crashing the system” and “hacking the real world.”

The problem is, those two categories don’t reflect reality. The categories of people he’s describing—totalitarians and anarchists—are mere caricatures of copyright combatants. Yes, many CEOs and Republicrats (since the two parties are largely indistinguishable on this topic) would like to tighten the screws and enclose the creative commons by extending copyright for longer and longer periods of time, restricting freedom of data movement and controlling media copying and (re)distribution. And yes, a few of the “hackers” of the creative commons want to completely defy all law and make everything available for détournment all the time. There are, however, large masses of people—consumers, especially, but politicians and business people as well—who are more or less in the middle and who do and will exert authority and change on the situation. Vaidhyanathan doesn’t ignore this middle ground but he only mentions it in passing, as it isn’t convenient to his hyperbolic thesis of apocalypse.

There’s another, deeper, multifaceted problem with The Anarchist in the Library, though, and that is the question of its accuracy. In the first place, the book is redolent with typographical errors, including in quoted material and often to the extent that the errors obfuscate the meaning and intention of both Vaidhyanathan and his quoted sources. Book editing is, admittedly, at a nadir and copyeditors have joined the other unwanted homeless people of America, having been discarded by the industry in favor of vast hordes of marketing types. Nevertheless, the edition of The Anarchist in the Library under review here is technically the second (the paperback reprint) and Vaidhyanathan could have put his foot down and insisted that the most egregious of the errors be corrected.

But maybe Vaidhyanathan wasn’t paying attention. The second source of worry regarding the accuracy of this book is solely the responsibility of the author. For example, Vaidhyanathan offers Diogenes of Sinope, known as the Cynic or the Dog, as an archetypal example of an “anarchist.” Vaidhyanathan writes: “Diogenes of Sinope… was infamous. Wearing only a shabby robe, he wandered the streets of Athens and then Sinope after he was expelled for defacing the Athenian currency.” This is exactly backwards, and the source cited by Vaidhyanathan for this information (a well-respected scholarly anthology edited by Branham and Goulet-Caze) gets it exactly right. Diogenes was born and raised in Sinope; his father was the minter of that Black Sea port. When the father (most likely) got in trouble for “defacing the currency,” Diogenes the son scrammed and wound up in Athens. Diogenes was about forty when he got to Athens, and it was there that he became the second-most famous man in the world after Alexander the Great, Diogenes’ younger contemporary. Vaidhyanathan’s source gets this right because, in fact, there is only one ancient source for the biography of Diogenes of Sinope and that is another Diogenes, this time Laertes, who lived some 500 years after the Cynic. So it’s remarkable that Vaidhyanathan would get this famous story so very wrong, and one has to wonder what else he has mangled.

Then there’s the matter of his use of anarchism as one of the poles of his apocalyptic thesis. Vaidhyanathan offers a capsule history of anarchism which compresses the highly divisive story of its development into a smooth space convenient to his purposes. Anybody who has studied anarchism, however, realizes that you get as many versions and as many historical emphases as you have anarchists in a room discussing the matter. That’d be fine if Vaidhyanathan acknowledged his oversimplification, but he doesn’t.

In short, I don’t trust Vaidhyanathan’s book. It’s written in a lively and entertaining style but the errors are so widespread as to offset any value it might have as a source of information. Vaidhyanathan’s naïf-like appropriation of anarchism is romantic, at best. While I give him credit for recognizing that “moral panics” (as in the case of record companies arguing they’ll be destroyed by illegal downloading) are created in order to manipulate public acceptance of restrictive copyright and IP law, I think he misses a key historical point: capitalism has always thrived on cultural crisis. This is not news and it is not going to “crash the system.

[Originally published in Curled Up with a Good Book] ( )
  funkendub | Sep 30, 2010 |
The title of the book and the slow beginning almost stopped me from giving serious consideration to this book. Fortunately I held on through all the ever widening turns to see how the author developed his point.

It became obvious that the complexity of his chosen subject required a great deal of introduction as well as research on his part. Slowly I warmed to the scope and the direction of the book, and found that the conclusion was well formed and fulfilling.

I was relieved that Vaidhyanathan avoided making any sweeping definitive conclusions or throwing his support toward either extremist camp. This book serves as a great primer to the intersection of copyright, intellectual property, technology, and culture. His neutral standing and emphasis on a need to discuss the topics seriously was a great change from the typical extremism from either side of the argument. ( )
  tyroeternal | Nov 1, 2009 |
A Critical Message Lost in the Haze

I had a graduate school professor who used to talk about his fog index.

This professor of Communications Theory believed, as do I, that writers and teachers who understand their material, are capable of expressing themselves in simple, declarative sentences. Those did not understand their material, went his corollary, resorted to compound, complex sentences to mask their lack of understanding. This continuum, he termed “The Fog Index.”

Unfortunately for me, this was probably the only lecture by this professor I understood that semester.

In this book Siva Vaidhyanathan posits there are dangers posed by the increasing speed and amount of information available. We resort, he says, to technological fixes to avoid discussions of the often complex and serious issues presented by this explosion.

This conflict manifests itself when someone invents a device, algorithm or law that moves the system of digital information towards freer distribution. The other side responds by pushing the distribution system back into their previous restraints.

The book outlines several examples:

• The battle to control public libraries, which are seen as breeding grounds for terrorism and pornography.
• Attempts to restrict the use and distribution of encryption technology to prevent it from falling into the hands of terrorists and criminals.
• Efforts by governments to regulate personal computers and networks to control illicit flows of material.
• Commercial and governmental efforts to regulate science and mathematics, including the human genome.

Unfortunately for me, and I believe, society, that is about all I understood. Vaidynanathan’s arguments get lost in his fogged-in writing style. Hopefully, time will bring clarity to his writing. His message is critical to a society that treasurers its civil liberties. ( )
  PointedPundit | Mar 29, 2008 |
Viser 1-5 af 8 (næste | vis alle)
ingen anmeldelser | tilføj en anmeldelse
Du bliver nødt til at logge ind for at redigere data i Almen Viden.
For mere hjælp se Almen Viden hjælpesiden.
Kanonisk titel
Originaltitel
Alternative titler
Oprindelig udgivelsesdato
Personer/Figurer
Vigtige steder
Vigtige begivenheder
Beslægtede film
Indskrift
Tilegnelse
Første ord
Citater
Sidste ord
Oplysning om flertydighed
Forlagets redaktører
Bagsidecitater
Originalsprog
Canonical DDC/MDS
Canonical LCC

Henvisninger til dette værk andre steder.

Wikipedia på engelsk (2)

"The recording industry has sued the music downloaders into submission, but as a model of communication, their effects still echo around the world. The proliferation of such peer-to-peer networks may appear to threaten many established institutions, and the backlash against them could be even worse than the problems they create. Their effects - good and bad - resonate far beyond markets for music. They are altering our sense of the possible, extending our cultural and political imaginations." "Unregulated networks of communication have existed as long as gossip has. But with the rise of electronic communication, they are exponentially more important. And they are drawing the contours of a struggle over information that will determine much of the culture and politics of our century, from unauthorized fan edits of Star Wars to terrorist organizations' reliance on "leaderless resistance." The Anarchist in the Library is the first guide to one of the most important cultural and economic developments of our time."--Jacket.

No library descriptions found.

Beskrivelse af bogen
Haiku-resume

Current Discussions

Ingen

Populære omslag

Quick Links

Vurdering

Gennemsnit: (3.4)
0.5
1 1
1.5
2 6
2.5 1
3 26
3.5 2
4 18
4.5 3
5 5

Er det dig?

Bliv LibraryThing-forfatter.

 

Om | Kontakt | LibraryThing.com | Brugerbetingelser/Håndtering af brugeroplysninger | Hjælp/FAQs | Blog | Butik | APIs | TinyCat | Efterladte biblioteker | Tidlige Anmeldere | Almen Viden | 202,660,098 bøger! | Topbjælke: Altid synlig