| Titler | Rækkefølge |
| Out of the Blue af Alaina Hawthorne | Best First Book, 1990 |
| Black Horse Island af Dee Holmes | Best First Book, 1991 |
| Candle in the Window af Christina Dodd | Best First Book, 1992 |
| Trust Me af Jeane Renick | Best First Book, 1993 |
| A Candle in the Dark af Megan Chance | Best First Book, 1994 |
| Ghostly Enchantment af Angie Ray | Best First Book, 1995 |
| The Warlord af Elizabeth Elliott | Best First Book, 1996 |
| Stardust of Yesterday af Lynn Kurland | Best First Book; Best Paranormal, 1997 |
| Brazen Angel af Elizabeth Boyle | Best First Book, 1998 |
| My Darling Caroline af Adele Ashworth | Best First Book, 1999 |
| The Lady and the Unicorn af Isolde Martyn | Best First Book, 2000 |
| A Man Like Mac af Fay Robinson | Best First Book, 2001 |
| The Border Bride af Elizabeth English | Best First Book, 2002 |
| Shades of Honor af Wendy Lindstrom | Best First Book, 2003 |
| Back Roads af Susan Crandall | Best First Book, 2004 |
| Time Off for Good Behavior af Lani Diane Rich | Best First Book, 2005 |
| Show Her the Money af Stephanie Feagan | Best First Book, 2006 |
| Hertugens Brud af Tracy Anne Warren | Best First Book, 2007 |
| Dead Girls Are Easy af Terri Garey | Best First Book, 2008 |
| Oh. My. Gods. af Tera Lynn Childs | Best First Book, 2009 |
| One Scream Away af Kate Brady | Best First Book, 2010 |
| Pieces of Sky af Kaki Warner | Best First Book, 2011 |
| First Grave on the Right af Darynda Jones | Best First Book, 2012 |
| The Haunting of Maddy Clare af Simone St. James | Best First Book; Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2013 |
| The Sweet Spot af Laura Drake | Best First Book, 2014 |
| Deception So Deadly af Clara Kensie | Best First Book, 2015 |
| Forget Tomorrow af Pintip Dunn | Best First Book, 2016 |
| Once and For All af Cheryl Etchison | Best First Book, 2017 |
| Take the Lead af Alexis Daria | Best First Book, 2018 |
| The Ice Cream Man af Kathleen Korbel | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1990 |
| Night of the Hunter af Jennifer Greene | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1990 |
| Private Relations af Diane Chamberlain | Best Contemporary Single Title, 1990 |
| Rhapsody in Bloom af Mona van Wieren | Best Traditional Romance, 1990 |
| Patrick Gallagher's Widow af Cheryl Reavis | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1991 |
| Step into My Parlor af Jan Hudson | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1991 |
| Song of the Lorelei af Lucy Gordon | Best Traditional Romance, 1991 |
| A Rose for Maggie af Kathleen Korbel | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1992 |
| Human Touch af Glenda Sanders | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1992 |
| A Man to Die For af Eileen Dreyer | Best Contemporary Single Title, 1992 |
| Every Kind of Heaven af Bethany Campbell | Best Traditional Romance, 1992 |
| Time to Heal [aka The Silence of Midnight] af Karen Young | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1993 |
| Navarrone af Helen R. Myers | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1993 |
| This Time Forever af Kathleen Eagle | Best Contemporary Single Title, 1993 |
| Father Goose af Marie Ferrarella | Best Traditional Romance, 1993 |
| Dragonslayer af Emilie Richards | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1994 |
| Avenging Angel af Tara Janzen | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1994 |
| Private Scandals af Nora Roberts | Best Contemporary Single Title, 1994 |
| Annie and the Wise Men af Lindsay Longford | Best Traditional Romance, 1994 |
| A Soldier's Heart af Kathleen Korbel | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1995 |
| Getting Rid of Bradley af Jennifer Crusie | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1995 |
| Again af Kathleen Gilles Seidel | Best Contemporary Single Title, 1995 |
| Oh, Baby! af Lauryn Chandler | Best Traditional Romance, 1995 |
| The Morning Side of Dawn af Justine Davis | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1996 |
| Single Dad af Jennifer Greene | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1996 |
| Born in Ice af Nora Roberts | Best Romance of 1995 [Awarded 1996]; Best Contemporary Single Title, 1996 |
| Stranger in Her Arms af Lorna Michaels | Best Traditional Romance, 1996 |
| Wild Blood af Naomi Horton | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1997 |
| Cowboy Pride af Anne McAllister | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1997 |
| Daniel's Gift af Barbara Freethy | Best Contemporary Single Title, 1997 |
| Her Very Own Husband (Silhouette Romance) af Lauryn Chandler | Best Traditional Romance, 1997 |
| Reckless af Ruth Wind | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1998 |
| Nobody's Princess af Jennifer Greene | Best Short Contemporary Series, 1998 |
| Nobody's Baby But Mine af Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Favorite Book of 1997 [Awarded 1998]; Best Contemporary Single Title, 1998 |
| His Brother's Child af Lucy Gordon | Best Traditional Romance, 1998 |
| Meant to Be Married af Ruth Wind | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 1999 |
| The Notorious Groom af Caroline Cross | *RETITLED Category* - Best Short Contemporary, 1999 |
| Dream a Little Dream af Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Best Contemporary Single Title, 1999 |
| Monday Man af Kristin Gabriel | Best Traditional Romance, 1999 |
| A Holiday Secret aka Undercover Princess af Suzanne Brockmann | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2000 |
| The Stardust Cowboy af Anne McAllister | Best Short Contemporary, 2000 |
| Bodyguard af Suzanne Brockmann | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2000 |
| Annie, Get Your Groom af Kristin Gabriel | Best Traditional Romance, 2000 |
| Rogue's Reform af Marilyn Pappano | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2001 |
| It Takes a Rebel af Stephanie Bond | Best Short Contemporary, 2001 |
| First Lady af Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2001 |
| The Best Man and the Bridesmaid af Liz Fielding | Best Traditional Romance, 2001 |
| Coming Home to You af Fay Robinson | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2002 |
| Long Hot Christmas af Barbara Daly | Best Short Contemporary, 2002 |
| True Confessions af Rachel Gibson | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2002 |
| Quinn's Complete Seduction af Sandra Steffen | Best Traditional Romance, 2002 |
| Taking Cover af Catherine Mann | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2003 |
| Taming the Outlaw af Cindy Gerard | Best Short Contemporary, 2003 |
| No Place Like Home af Barbara Samuel | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2003 |
| The Christmas Basket af Debbie Macomber | Best Traditional Romance, 2003 |
| The Top Gun's Return af Kathleen Creighton | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2004 |
| The Knight's Kiss af Nicole Burnham | Best Short Contemporary, 2004 |
| Fortidens skygger af Nora Roberts | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2004 |
| Her Royal Baby af Marion Lennox | Best Traditional Romance, 2004 |
| John Riley's Girl af Inglath Cooper | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2005 |
| Miss Pruitt's Private Life af Barbara McCauley | Best Short Contemporary, 2005 |
| Bet Me af Jennifer Crusie | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2005 |
| Christmas Eve Marriage af Jessica Hart | Best Traditional Romance, 2005 |
| Worth Every Risk af Dianna Love Snell | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2006 |
| The Marriage Miracle af Liz Fielding | Best Short Contemporary, 2006 |
| Lakeside Cottage af Susan Wiggs | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2006 |
| Princess of Convenience af Marion Lennox | Best Traditional Romance, 2006 |
| A Mom for Tim [aka The Mommy Quest] af Lori Handeland | Best Long Contemporary Romance, 2007 |
| From the First af Jessica Bird | Best Short Contemporary, 2007 |
| Adios to My Old Life af Caridad Ferrer | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2007 |
| Claiming His Family af Barbara Hannay | Best Traditional Romance, 2007 |
| Snowbound af Janice Kay Johnson | *NEWLY COMBINED Category* - Best Contemporary Series, 2008 |
| Catch of the Day af Kristan Higgins | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2008 |
| Treasure af Helen Brenna | *NEW Category* - Best Contemporary Series: Suspense/Adventure, 2008 |
| A Mother's Wish af Karen Templeton | Best Contemporary Series, 2009 |
| Not Another Bad Date af Rachel Gibson | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2009 |
| Danger Signals af Kathleen Creighton | Best Contemporary Series: Suspense/Adventure, 2009 |
| A Not-So-Perfect Past af Beth Andrews | Best Contemporary Series, 2010 |
| Too Good To Be True af Kristan Higgins | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2010 |
| The Soldier's Secret Daughter af Cindy Dees | Best Contemporary Series: Suspense/Adventure, 2010 |
| Welcome Home, Cowboy af Karen Templeton | Best Contemporary Series, 2011 |
| Simply Irresistible af Jill Shalvis | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2011 |
| The Moon That Night af Helen Brenna | Best Contemporary Series: Suspense/Adventure, 2011 |
| Doukakis's Apprentice af Sarah Morgan | Best Contemporary Series, 2012 |
| Boomerang Bride af Fiona Lowe | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2012 |
| Soldier's Last Stand af Cindy Dees | Best Contemporary Series: Suspense/Adventure, 2012 |
| A Gift for All Seasons af Karen Templeton | *REINSTATED Category* - Best Long Contemporary Series, 2013 |
| A Night of No Return af Sarah Morgan | *REINSTATED Category* - Best Short Contemporary Series, 2013 |
| The Way Back Home af Barbara Freethy | Best Contemporary Single Title, 2013 |
| Crazy Thing Called Love af Molly O'Keefe | *RETITLED Category* - Best Contemporary, 2014 |
| Why Resist a Rebel? af Leah Ashton | Best Short Contemporary, 2014 |
| Baby, It's You af Jane Graves | *RETITLED Category* - Contemporary Romance: Long, 2015 |
| One in a Million af Jill Shalvis | *NEW Category* - Contemporary Romance: Mid-Length, 2015 |
| A Texas Rescue Christmas af Caro Carson | *RETITLED Category* - Contemporary Romance: Short, 2015 |
| Brokedown Cowboy af Maisey Yates | Contemporary Romance: Long, 2016 |
| Him af Sarina Bowen | Contemporary Romance: Mid-Length, 2016 |
| The Nanny Plan af Sarah M. Anderson | Contemporary Romance: Short, 2016 |
| Miracle on 5th Avenue af Sarah Morgan | Contemporary Romance: Long, 2017 |
| Carolina Dreaming af Virginia Kantra | Contemporary Romance: Mid-Length, 2017 |
| Christmas on Crimson Mountain af Michelle Major | Contemporary Romance: Short, 2017 |
| Falling Hard af Lexi Ryan | Contemporary Romance: Long, 2018 |
| Tell Me af Abigail Strom | Contemporary Romance: Mid-Length, 2018 |
| Second Chance Summer af Kait Nolan | Contemporary Romance: Short, 2018 |
| Claim Me af J. Kenner | *NEW Category* - Best Erotic Romance, 2014 |
| The Saint af Tiffany Reisz | Best Erotic Romance, 2015 |
| For Real af Alexis Hall | Best Erotic Romance, 2016 |
| Off the Clock af Roni Loren | Best Erotic Romance, 2017 |
| Wicked Dirty af J. Kenner | Best Erotic Romance, 2018 |
| The Bride af Julie Garwood | Best Single Title Historical, 1990 |
| Silver Noose af Patricia Gardner Evans | Best Series Historical, 1990 |
| The Rake af Mary Jo Putney | Best Regency Historical, 1990 |
| Where Love Dwells af Elizabeth Stuart | Best Single Title Historical, 1991 |
| A Wild Yearning af Penelope Williamson | Best Series Historical, 1991 |
| The Sandalwood Princess af Loretta Chase | Best Regency Historical, 1991 |
| Courting Miss Hattie af Pamela Morsi | Best Single Title Historical, 1992 |
| The Tender Texan af Jodi Thomas | Best Series Historical, 1992 |
| Emily and the Dark Angel af Jo Beverley | Best Regency Historical, 1992 |
| Keeper of the Dream af Penelope Williamson | Best Single Title Historical, 1993 |
| The Prisoner af Cheryl Reavis | Best Historical Series, 1993 |
| An Unwilling Bride af Jo Beverley | Best Regency Historical, 1993 |
| My Lady Notorious af Jo Beverley | Best Historical Series, 1994 |
| Deirdre and Don Juan af Jo Beverley | Best Regency Historical, 1994 |
| Dancing on the Wind af Mary Jo Putney | *RETITLED Category* - Best Long Historical, 1995 |
| To Tame a Texan's Heart af Jodi Thomas | *RETITLED Category* - Best Historical, 1995 |
| Mrs. Drew Plays Her Hand af Carla Kelly | Best Regency Historical, 1995 |
| Something Shady af Pamela Morsi | Best Long Historical, 1996 |
| Lord of Scoundrels af Loretta Chase | Best Short Historical, 1996 |
| Gwen's Christmas Ghost af Lynn Kerstan | Best Regency Historical, 1996 |
| Conor's Way af Laura Lee Guhrke | Best Long Historical, 1997 |
| Always to Remember af Lorraine Heath | Best Short Historical, 1997 |
| The Lady's Companion af Carla Kelly | Best Regency Historical, 1997 |
| The Promise of Jenny Jones af Maggie Osborne | Best Long Historical, 1998 |
| Heart of a Knight af Barbara Samuel | Best Short Historical, 1998 |
| Love's Reward af Jean Ross Ewing | Best Regency Historical, 1998 |
| My Dearest Enemy af Connie Brockway | Best Long Historical, 1999 |
| Merely Married af Patricia Coughlin | Best Short Historical, 1999 |
| His Grace Endures af Emma Jensen | Best Regency Historical, 1999 |
| Silken Threads af Patricia Ryan | Best Long Historical, 2000 |
| The Proposition af Judith Ivory | Best Short Historical, 2000 |
| The Rake's Retreat af Nancy Butler | Best Regency Historical, 2000 |
| Devilish af Jo Beverley | Best Long Historical, 2001 |
| The Mistress af Susan Wiggs | Best Short Historical, 2001 |
| A Grand Design af Emma Jensen | Best Regency Historical, 2001 |
| The Bridal Season af Connie Brockway | Best Long Historical, 2002 |
| Tempt Me Twice af Barbara Dawson Smith | Best Short Historical, 2002 |
| Much Obliged af Jessica Benson | Best Regency Historical, 2002 |
| Stealing Heaven af Madeline Hunter | Best Long Historical, 2003 |
| The Bride Fair af Cheryl Reavis | Best Short Historical, 2003 |
| A Debt to Delia af Barbara Metzger | Best Regency Historical, 2003 |
| The Destiny af Kathleen Givens | Best Long Historical, 2004 |
| Worth Any Price af Lisa Kleypas | Best Short Historical, 2004 |
| Prospero's Daughter af Nancy Butler | Best Regency Historical, 2004 |
| Shadowheart af Laura Kinsale | Best Long Historical, 2005 |
| A Wanted Man af Susan Kay Law | Best Short Historical, 2005 |
| A Passionate Endeavor af Sophia Nash | Best Regency Historical, 2005 |
| The Devil to Pay af Liz Carlyle | Best Long Historical, 2006 |
| The Texan's Reward af Jodi Thomas | Best Short Historical, 2006 |
| A Reputable Rake af Diane Gaston | Best Regency Historical, 2006 |
| On the Way to the Wedding af Julia Quinn | Best Long Historical, 2007 |
| The Book of True Desires af Betina Krahn | Best Short Historical, 2007 |
| Lessons of Desire af Madeline Hunter | Best Historical, 2008 |
| The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever af Julia Quinn | Best Regency Historical, 2008 |
| The Edge of Impropriety af Pam Rosenthal | Best Historical, 2009 |
| My Lord and Spymaster af Joanna Bourne | Best Regency Historical, 2009 |
| Not Quite a Husband af Sherry Thomas | Best Historical, 2010 |
| What Happens in London af Julia Quinn | Best Regency Historical, 2010 |
| His at Night af Sherry Thomas | Best Historical, 2011 |
| The Mischief of the Mistletoe af Lauren Willig | Best Regency Historical, 2011 |
| The Black Hawk (Berkley Sensation) af Joanna Bourne | Best Historical, 2012 |
| A Night to Surrender af Tessa Dare | Best Regency Historical, 2012 |
| A Rogue by Any Other Name af Sarah MacLean | Best Historical, 2013 |
| No Good Duke Goes Unpunished af Sarah MacLean | Best Historical, 2014 |
| Fool Me Twice af Meredith Duran | *REINSTATED Category* - Historical Romance: Long, 2015 |
| Romancing the Duke af Tessa Dare | *REINSTATED Category* - Historical Romance: Short, 2015 |
| Tiffany Girl af Deeanne Gist | Historical Romance: Long, 2016 |
| It Started with a Scandal af Julie Anne Long | Historical Romance: Short, 2016 |
| No Mistress of Mine af Laura Lee Guhrke | Historical Romance: Long, 2017 |
| A Duke to Remember af Kelly Bowen | Historical Romance: Short, 2017 |
| Between the Devil and the Duke af Kelly Bowen | Historical Romance: Long, 2018 |
| Waltzing with the Earl af Catherine Tinley | Historical Romance: Short, 2018 |
| Morning Glory af LaVyrle Spencer | Best Romance of 1989; Awarded 1990 |
| The Prince of Midnight af Laura Kinsale | Best Romance of 1990, Awarded 1991 |
| Outlander af Diana Gabaldon | Best Romance of 1991, Awarded 1992 |
| Come Spring af Jill Marie Landis | Best Romance of 1992, Awarded 1993 |
| Lord of the Night af Susan Wiggs | Best Romance of 1993, Awarded 1994 |
| It Had to Be You af Susan Elizabeth Phillips | Best Romance of 1994; Awarded 1995 |
| Between Sisters af Kristin Hannah | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2004 |
| A.K.A. Goddess af Evelyn Vaughn | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2005 |
| Lady Luck's Map of Vegas af Barbara Samuel | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2006 |
| A Lady Raised High: A Novel of Anne Boleyn af Laurien Gardner | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2007 |
| Silent in the Grave af Deanna Raybourn | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2008 |
| Tribute af Nora Roberts | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2009 |
| The Lost Recipe for Happiness af Barbara O'Neal | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2010 |
| Welcome to Harmony af Jodi Thomas | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2011 |
| How to Bake a Perfect Life af Barbara O'Neal | Best Novel with Strong Romantic Elements, 2012 |
| The Moon in the Palace af Weina Dai Randel | *RETITLED Category* - Mainstream Fiction with a Central Romance, 2017 |
| Now That You Mention It af Kristan Higgins | Mainstream Fiction with a Central Romance, 2018 |
| Angel for Hire af Justine Davis | *NEW Category* - Best Futuristic/Fantasy/Paranormal, 1992 |
| Emily's Ghost af Antoinette Stockenberg | Best Futuristic/Fantasy/Paranormal, 1993 |
| Falling Angel af Anne Stuart | Best Futuristic/Fantasy/Paranormal, 1994 |
| Lord of the Storm af Justine Davis | *RETITLED Category* - Best Paranormal, 1995 |
| The Covenant af Modean Moon | Best Paranormal, 1996 |
| Fire Hawk af Justine Dare | Best Paranormal, 1998 |
| The Bride Finder af Susan Carroll | Best Paranormal, 1999 |
| Nell af Jeanette Baker | Best Paranormal, 2000 |
| The Highlander's Touch af Karen Marie Moning | Best Paranormal, 2001 |
| Heart Mate af Robin D. Owens | Best Paranormal, 2002 |
| Contact af Susan Grant | Best Paranormal, 2003 |
| Shades of Midnight af Linda Fallon | Best Paranormal, 2004 |
| Blue Moon af Lori Handeland | Best Paranormal, 2005 |
| Gabriel's Ghost af Linnea Sinclair | Best Paranormal, 2006 |
| A Hunger Like No Other af Kresley Cole | Best Paranormal, 2007 |
| Lover Revealed af J. R. Ward | Best Paranormal, 2008 |
| Seducing Mr. Darcy af Gwyn Cready | Best Paranormal, 2009 |
| Kiss of a Demon King af Kresley Cole | Best Paranormal, 2010 |
| Unchained af Sharon Ashwood | Best Paranormal, 2011 |
| Dragon Bound af Thea Harrison | Best Paranormal, 2012 |
| Shadow's Claim af Kresley Cole | Best Paranormal, 2013 |
| The Firebird af Susanna Kearsley | Best Paranormal, 2014 |
| Evernight af Kristen Callihan | Best Paranormal, 2015 |
| Must Love Chainmail af Angela Quarles | Best Paranormal, 2016 |
| The Pages of the Mind af Jeffe Kennedy | Best Paranormal, 2017 |
| Hunt the Darkness af Stephanie Rowe | Best Paranormal, 2018 |
| Special Report [anthology 3-in-1] af Merline Lovelace | *NEW Category* - Best Romantic Novella, 2001 |
| Wish List (I Will ∙ Puddings, Pastries, and Thou ∙ Union ∙ All I Want) af Lisa Kleypas | Best Romantic Novella, 2002 |
| Tapestry [Anthology] af Lynn Kurland | Best Romantic Novella, 2003 |
| The Wedding Chase (In His Lordship's Bed / Prisoner of the Tower / Word of a Gentleman) af Kasey Michaels | Best Romantic Novella, 2004 |
| Night's Edge (Her Best Enemy | Someone Else's Shadow | Dancers in the Dark) af Maggie Shayne | Best Romantic Novella, 2005 |
| The Naked Truth (4-in-1) af Donna Kauffman | Best Romantic Novella, 2006 |
| A NASCAR Holiday (Anthology, 3-in-1) af Kimberly Raye | Best Romantic Novella, 2007 |
| Like Mother, Like Daughter : But in a Good Way [3-in-1] af Jennifer Greene | *RETITLED Category* - Best Romance Novella, 2008 |
| It Happened One Night [Anthology 4-in-1] af Stephanie Laurens | Best Romance Novella, 2009 |
| The Night Before Christmas (On a Snowy Christmas / The Christmas Baby / The Christmas Eve Promise) af Brenda Novak | Best Romance Novella, 2010 |
| Burning Up [Anthology 4-in-1] af Angela Knight | Best Romance Novella, 2011 |
| I Love the Earl [novella] af Caroline Linden | Best Romance Novella, 2012 |
| Seduced by a Pirate af Eloisa James | Best Romance Novella, 2013 |
| Take Me, Cowboy af Jane Porter | Best Romance Novella, 2014 |
| His Road Home af Anna Richland | Best Romance Novella, 2015 |
| Nice Girls Don't Ride af Roni Loren | Best Romance Novella, 2016 |
| Her Every Wish [novella] af Courtney Milan | Best Romance Novella, 2017 |
| Forbidden River [novella] af Brynn Kelly | Best Romance Novella, 2018 |
| An Echo in the Darkness af Francine Rivers | *NEW Category* - Best Inspirational, 1995 |
| As Sure as the Dawn af Francine Rivers | Best Inspirational, 1996 |
| The Scarlet Thread af Francine Rivers | Best Inspirational, 1997 |
| Homeward af Melody Carlson | Best Inspirational, 1998 |
| Patterns of Love af Robin Lee Hatcher | Best Inspirational, 1999 |
| Danger in the Shadows af Dee Henderson | Best Inspirational, 2000 |
| The Shepherd's Voice af Robin Lee Hatcher | Best Inspirational, 2001 |
| Beneath a Southern Sky af Deborah Raney | Best Inspirational, 2002 |
| Never Say Goodbye af Irene Hannon | Best Inspirational, 2003 |
| Autumn Dreams af Gayle Roper | Best Inspirational, 2004 |
| Grounds to Believe af Shelley Bates | Best Inspirational, 2005 |
| Heavens to Betsy af Beth Pattillo | Best Inspirational, 2006 |
| Revealed af Tamera Alexander | Best Inspirational, 2007 |
| A Touch of Grace af Linda Goodnight | Best Inspirational, 2008 |
| Finding Stefanie af Susan May Warren | Best Inspirational, 2009 |
| The Inheritance af Tamera Alexander | Best Inspirational, 2010 |
| In Harm's Way af Irene Hannon | Best Inspirational, 2011 |
| The Measure of Katie Calloway af Serena B. Miller | Best Inspirational, 2012 |
| Against the Tide af Elizabeth Camden | Best Inspirational, 2013 |
| Five Days in Skye af Carla Laureano | Best Inspirational, 2014 |
| Deceived af Irene Hannon | Best Inspirational, 2015 |
| A Noble Masquerade af Kristi Ann Hunter | Best Inspirational, 2016 |
| My Hope Next Door af Tammy L Gray | *RETITLED Category* - Best Romance with Religious or Spiritual Elements, 2017 |
| Then There Was You af Kara Isaac | Best Romance with Religious or Spiritual Elements, 2018 |
| Perchance to Dream af Kathleen Korbel | Best Romantic Suspense, 1990 |
| Night Spice af Karen Keast | Best Romantic Suspense, 1991 |
| Night Shift af Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 1992 |
| Divine Evil af Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 1993 |
| Nightshade af Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 1994 |
| Hidden Riches af Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 1995 |
| Winter's Edge af Anne Stuart | Best Romantic Suspense, 1996 |
| See How They Run af Marilyn Campbell | Best Romantic Suspense, 1997 |
| On the Way to a Wedding af Ingrid Weaver | Best Romantic Suspense, 1998 |
| Cool Shade af Theresa Weir | Best Romantic Suspense, 1999 |
| Keeper of the Bride af Tess Gerritsen | Best Romantic Suspense, 2000 |
| Carolina Moon af Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 2001 |
| The Surgeon af Tess Gerritsen | Best Romantic Suspense, 2002 |
| Skæbnens gudinder af Nora Roberts | Best Romantic Suspense, 2003 |
| Remember When af J. D. Robb | Best Romantic Suspense, 2004 |
| I'm Watching You af Karen Rose | Best Romantic Suspense, 2005 |
| Survivor in Death af J. D. Robb | Best Romantic Suspense, 2006 |
| Blackout af Annie Solomon | Best Romantic Suspense, 2007 |
| Ice Blue af Anne Stuart | Best Romantic Suspense, 2008 |
| Take No Prisoners af Cindy Gerard | Best Romantic Suspense, 2009 |
| Whisper of Warning af Laura Griffin | Best Romantic Suspense, 2010 |
| Silent Scream af Karen Rose | Best Romantic Suspense, 2011 |
| New York to Dallas af J. D. Robb | Best Romantic Suspense, 2012 |
| Scorched af Laura Griffin | Best Romantic Suspense, 2013 |
| Off the Edge af Carolyn Crane | Best Romantic Suspense, 2014 |
| Concealed in Death af J. D. Robb | Best Romantic Suspense, 2015 |
| Flash Fire af Dana Marton | Best Romantic Suspense, 2016 |
| Repressed af Elisabeth Naughton | Best Romantic Suspense, 2017 |
| The Fixer af HelenKay Dimon | Best Romantic Suspense, 2018 |
| Renee af Vivian Schurfranz | Best Young Adult Romance, 1990 |
| Now I Lay Me Down to Sleep af Lurlene McDaniel | Best Young Adult Romance, 1992 |
| Song of the Buffalo Boys af Sherry Garland | Best Young Adult Romance, 1993 |
| Summer Lightning af Wendy Corsi Staub | Best Young Adult Romance, 1994 |
| Aislinns Valg: Wicked Lovely (1) af Melissa Marr | *REINSTATED Category* - Best Young Adult Romance, 2008 |
| Hell Week af Rosemary Clement-Moore | Best Young Adult Romance, 2009 |
| Perfect Chemistry af Simone Elkeles | Best Young Adult Romance, 2010 |
| The Iron King af Julie Kagawa | Best Young Adult Romance, 2011 |
| Enclave af Ann Aguirre | Best Young Adult Romance, 2012 |
| The Farm af Emily McKay | Best Young Adult Romance, 2013 |
| Boys Like You af Juliana Stone | Best Young Adult Romance, 2015 |
| The Anatomical Shape of a Heart af Jenn Bennett | Best Young Adult Romance, 2016 |
| The Problem With Forever af Jennifer L. Armentrout | Best Young Adult Romance, 2017 |
| Seize Today af Pintip Dunn | Best Young Adult Romance, 2018 |
