| Titler | Rækkefølge |
| Julius Knipl, Real Estate Photographer: Stories af Ben Katchor | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1997 |
| På sporet af Peter Pan, 2. del af Cosey | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1997 |
| Frank Vol. 2 (Frank) af Jim Woodring | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1998 |
| The Little Man: Short Strips, 1980-1995 af Chester Brown | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1998 |
| The End of the Century Club: Countdown (v. 1) af Ed Hillyer | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1999 |
| The Hey Mister Celebrity Roast af Pete Sickman-Garner | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1999 |
| Hicksville af Dylan Horrocks | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1999 |
| Tiny Bubbles af James Kochalka | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 1999 |
| Clan Apis af Jay Hosler | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2000 |
| Comix 2000 af L'Association | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2000 |
| Drawn and Quarterly, Volume 3 af Chris Oliveros | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2000 |
| New Hat Stories: Banks/Eubanks af Tom Hart | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2000 |
| Box Office Poison af Alex Robinson | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2001 |
| Jimmy Corrigan : den klogeste dreng i verden af Chris Ware | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2001 |
| Mail Order Bride af Mark Kalesniko | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2001 |
| Safe Area Gorazde : the War in Eastern Bosnia 1992-95 af Joe Sacco | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2001 |
| Snake 'n' Bacon's Cartoon Cabaret af Michael Kupperman | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2001 |
| Fallout: J. Robert Oppenheimer, Leo Szilard, and the Political Science of the Atomic Bomb af Jim Ottaviani | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2002 |
| Haw! af Ivan Brunetti | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2002 |
| Non #5 af Jordan Crane | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2002 |
| The Summer of Love af Debbie Drechsler | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2002 |
| Beg the Question (A Minimum Wage Collection) af Bob Fingerman | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2003 |
| The Frank Book af Jim Woodring | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2003 |
| Nightmare Alley af Spain Rodriguez | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2003 |
| Det store onde af David B. | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2003 |
| The Fixer: A Story from Sarajevo af Joe Sacco | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2004 |
| Louis Riel : a comic-strip biography af Chester Brown | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2004 |
| McSweeney's Issue 13 (McSweeney's Quarterly Concern): The Comics Issue af Dave Eggers | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2004 |
| Teratoid Heights af Matt Brinkman | Outstanding Graphic Novel or Collection, 2004 |
| Above & Below: Two Stories of the American Frontier af James Sturm | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2005 |
| Bighead af Jeffrey Brown | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2005 |
| Carnet de voyage af Craig Thompson | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2005 |
| Cinema Panopticum af Thomas Ott | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2005 |
| Dead Herring Comics af Actus | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2005 |
| Fred the clown af Roger Langridge | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2005 |
| Hutch Owen: Unmarketable af Tom Hart | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2005 |
| Why Are You Doing This? af Jason | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2005 |
| Bedemandens datter : en tragikomisk familiehistorie af Alison Bechdel | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2006 |
| Castle Waiting af Linda Medley | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2006 |
| The Clouds Above af Jordan Crane | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2006 |
| Drawn & Quarterly Showcase: Book Three af Chris Oliveros | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2006 |
| The Push Man and Other Stories af Yoshihiro Tatsumi | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2006 |
| Squirrel Mother af Megan Kelso | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2006 |
| The Ticking af Renee French | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2006 |
| Wimbledon Green af Seth | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2006 |
| Aya fra Yopougon af Marguerite Abouet | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2007 |
| Bookhunter af Jason Shiga | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2007 |
| Drawn & Quarterly Showcase: Book Four (Drawn & Quarterly) af Chris Oliveros | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2007 |
| House af Josh Simmons | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2007 |
| King-Cat Classix af John Porcellino | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2007 |
| Misery Loves Comedy af Ivan Brunetti | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2007 |
| Moomin: The Complete Tove Jansson Comic Strip, Book 1 af Tove Jansson | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2007 |
| Åbne sår af Rutu Modan | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2007 |
| Hot Breath of War af Trevor Alixopulos | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2008 |
| Notes for a War Story af Gipi | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2008 |
| Paul Goes Fishing af Michel Rabagliati | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2008 |
| Spent af Joe Matt | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2008 |
| Disappearance Diary af Hideo Azuma | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2009 |
| Drop-in af Dave Lapp | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2009 |
| Nicolas (A Petit Livre) af Pascal Girard | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2009 |
| You'll Never Know, Book One: A Good and Decent Man af C. Tyler | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2009 |
| The Complete Jack Survives af Jerry Moriarty | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2010 |
| Pim & Francie: "The Golden Bear Days" af Al Columbia | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2010 |
| The Summit of the Gods, Volume 1 af Jirô Taniguchi | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2010 |
| Years of the elephant af Willy Linthout | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2010 |
| The Heavy Hand af Chris Cilla | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2011 |
| How Mirka Got Her Sword af Barry Deutsch | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2011 |
| Special Exits: A Graphic Memoir af Joyce Farmer | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2011 |
| You'll Never Know, Book Two: Collateral Damage af C. Tyler | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2011 |
| Harvey Pekar's Cleveland af Harvey Pekar | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2012 |
| My Friend Dahmer af Derf Backderf | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2012 |
| Troop 142 af Mike Dawson | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2012 |
| A Zoo in Winter af Jirô Taniguchi | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2012 |
| The Property af Rutu Modan | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2013 |
| Susceptible af Geneviève Castrée | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2013 |
| When David Lost His Voice af Judith Vanistendael | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2013 |
| You'll Never Know, Book Three: Soldier's Heart af C. Tyler | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2013 |
| Amazing Facts and Beyond af Kevin Huizenga | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2014 |
| The Amazing, Enlightening And Absolutely True Adventures of Katherine Whaley af Kim Deitch | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2014 |
| The Boxer: The True Story of Holocaust Survivor Harry Haft af Reinhard Kleist | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2014 |
| Boxers & Saints Boxed Set af Gene Luen Yang | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2014 |
| The End af Anders Nilsen | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2014 |
| Eye of the Majestic Creature #2 af Leslie Stein | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2014 |
| Sock Monkey Treasury: A "Tony Millionaire's Sock Monkey" Collection af Tony Millionaire | Outstanding Anthology or Collection, 2014 |
| War of Streets and Houses af Sophie Yanow | Outstanding Graphic Novel, 2014 |
